A tenant texts at 9 p.m. The AC is blowing warm air, or a faucet won’t stop dripping, or a window blind just snapped off. Your first question is always the same. Whose job is this? Answering that correctly is a big piece of what landlords are responsible for in rental property maintenance, and it’s where owners lose either money or goodwill.
This post is for rental owners who want a simple way to sort repairs between landlord and tenant. We cover the usual split, the gray areas that cause deposit fights, what local seasons do to your repair list, and a quick way to triage requests as they come in.
We manage 340 properties in Athens and have been at it for 8 years, so we’ve heard every version of “that’s not my job.” Most of those arguments are avoidable.
“We manage 340 properties in Athens and have been at it for 8 years, so we’ve heard every version of “that’s not my job.””
In This Guide
The Basic Split Between Owner and Tenant
A rule of thumb that holds up most of the time. Things that wear out with age are the owner’s problem. Things a tenant breaks or neglects are the tenant’s.
| Issue | Who usually pays | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Dead HVAC compressor | Owner | Aging system, normal use |
| Water heater stops working | Owner | Aging system |
| Roof leak | Owner | Structure |
| Clogged drain from wipes or grease | Tenant | Misuse |
| Smoke detector battery | Tenant | Routine upkeep |
| Window broken by a thrown ball | Tenant | Tenant-caused damage |
Georgia law gives landlords some repair duties, so check the current rule. Don’t assume a lease clause can hand every repair to the tenant. Have a Georgia real estate attorney review any lease language that tries.
The state rules are the same whether you own a duplex for rent in Athens, GA or rental properties in Watkinsville, GA. Local codes can differ, so check those too.
What Your Lease Should Spell Out
The table covers the obvious stuff. Leases earn their keep on everything else. A good one answers these before anyone has to ask:
- Yard care: Who mows, who trims, and who pays if the HOA fines the property.
- Pest control: Which pests are the owner’s problem and which are the tenant’s.
- Filter changes: Tenants often change HVAC filters every one to three months. Put it in writing.
- Small items: Light bulbs, smoke detector batteries and similar routine upkeep.
- Reporting: Every request goes through the tenant portal so there’s a timestamp.
- Pets: What’s allowed, and who pays when a pet causes damage.
If the lease is silent, the argument gets expensive.
The Gray Areas That Start Deposit Fights
Clear cases are easy. Gray areas are where owners and tenants end up in magistrate court.
Normal Wear Versus Damage
A worn path in the hallway carpet after three years is normal wear. A burn mark or a pet stain is damage. Faded paint is wear. A hole from a mounted TV that came down is damage.
Picture a landlord who assumes a snapped window blind is routine maintenance. It’s usually tenant-caused damage from misuse. Multiply that confusion across dozens of small items at move-out, and hundreds of dollars quietly leave the deposit deduction column and land on the owner.
Student housing makes this worse. UGA enrolls roughly 40,000 students, and homes near campus turn over often. A 1 bedroom for rent in Athens, GA near campus may see a new tenant every year, which means a new wear-and-tear debate every year.
Pet Damage
Pets are a gray area owners tend to underestimate. With our Pet Damage Protection, if an approved pet causes damage, we handle the repair costs at no extra charge to the owner. That takes one common argument off the table.
Why the Move-In Report Settles Most Arguments
Most owners think proving tenant damage is easy. It isn’t. Without a detailed move-in report the tenant has signed, you may have no baseline, and you can end up eating damage you never caused.
Skip the signed move-in condition report and you can lose a deposit dispute in magistrate court even when the damage is real. Georgia law sets a firm deadline for returning the deposit after the lease ends and the tenant moves out (O.C.G.A. § 44-7-34), so you need your proof ready before that clock starts.
A solid move-in report includes:
- Dated photos or video of every room, closet and appliance
- Notes on existing scuffs, stains and worn spots
- The working condition of HVAC, smoke detectors and appliances
- The tenant’s signature and date, stored where you can find it in two minutes
It’s boring paperwork. It’s also the cheapest insurance you’ll ever buy.
What Summer Heat and the Student Calendar Do to Your Repair List
Local conditions change who needs what, and when.
Heat, Humidity and Aging Systems
Summers here regularly top 90°F with heavy humidity, so HVAC failures hit hard. Typical HVAC repairs in a single-family rental often run $500 to $1,500. A licensed plumber or HVAC service call generally runs $75 to $200 before parts.
Winters are mild but occasionally freeze, and that’s when exposed pipes cause trouble. A house in Normaltown with decades-old plumbing tests a repair budget differently than a newer duplex.
Say an owner defers an HVAC repair through July because it seems minor. The tenant has put the request in writing, and the unit becomes genuinely hard to live in. Now the owner has a legal problem on top of a repair problem.
Treat a dead AC in a Georgia summer as urgent. A repair request you ignored on paper can turn into a legal claim, and state law gives landlords repair duties, so know the current rule.
The Academic Calendar
Move-outs bunch up from May through July. Move-ins crunch in late July and August. That squeezes inspections, repairs and turnover into a few short weeks, and a slow repair in June can mean an empty unit in August.
How to Triage a Maintenance Request in One Minute
Plenty of free landlord tips in Athens, GA say “respond fast.” Speed without sorting just creates chaos. Sort first, then fix.
- Act now: Active water leak, no AC in extreme heat, no heat in a freeze, gas smell, sparking outlets, broken exterior locks. Same-day response.
- Schedule soon: Slow leak, running toilet, a dead appliance, a stuck window. Book a licensed vendor within the next week or so.
- Can wait: Cosmetic scuffs, sticky drawers, touch-up paint. Batch these with the next inspection or turnover.
Here’s why the middle bucket matters. Say a $150 plumber visit fixes a slow leak today. Ignore that leak for two months and it can grow into a $3,000 to $8,000 mold remediation job. Deferring maintenance rarely saves money.
A one-minute sort keeps a $150 call from becoming a $3,000 problem. Treat “can wait” as a schedule, not a pile you forget.
This checklist helps you sort every repair request in about a minute and handle each one the same way, start to finish.
Free checklist
Maintenance request triage checklist
Sort every repair request in a minute: what needs action now, what needs scheduling soon, and what can wait. Then handle each one the same way, start to finish.
0 of 20 done
Set up before anything breaks
Emergency: act now
Urgent: schedule right away
Routine: schedule normally
For every request
Your ticks stay in this browser only.
Licensed Pros, No Markup and a Paper Trail
Why Licensed Work Matters
Cheap handymen are tempting. But if an unlicensed contractor does electrical or plumbing work and something goes wrong, the owner can face liability that insurance may not cover. Certain repair categories in Georgia licensed contractors in Georgia legally require, so check before you hire.
We use licensed, insured professionals for repairs. We don’t mark up repairs or maintenance. Invoices pass through, and you pay exactly what the vendor billed us.
What a Paper Trail Looks Like
Say an owner fixes a leaky faucet without writing anything down. Two months later the pipe fails. With no record showing who did the original work and when, it’s hard to tell a landlord-side failure from tenant-caused damage.
Here’s what a clean record includes:
- Tenant requests entered through the online portal, with timestamps
- Every repair invoice listed on your monthly statement
- Owner statements and invoices available through the portal anytime, day or night
- Annual inspections to catch small problems before they become repair requests
With an 8% management fee and no markup, the vendor’s bill is the bill. Owners see the same invoice we see, along with quick answers when they have questions.
If you list houses for rent in Athens, GA by owner, you’re the one reading that 9 p.m. text. And if you read property management Athens GA reviews, look at how people talk about repairs. That tells you more than any fee sheet.
Entry Notice and Tenant Communication
Repairs mean someone has to go inside. Georgia doesn’t set an exact number of hours for landlord entry notice. Many landlords give about a day’s notice as a courtesy, and your lease should state the notice period clearly. Emergencies like an active leak are different, and you can usually act right away.
Tenants notice how you handle this. One tenant who has rented under three different companies said Iron Horse was “far and away” the best and called us “prompt to maintenance requests.” Quick responses and clear notice build the kind of tenant who renews.
If keeping up with repair requests feels harder than it should, we’re open to a conversation.
FAQ
Who pays when the AC breaks in a rental?
Usually the owner, when the system fails from age or normal use. The tenant may owe the cost if they caused the damage or ignored a lease duty like changing filters. Typical HVAC repairs often run $500 to $1,500.
Can I charge a tenant for normal wear and tear?
Generally no. Deposit deductions are meant for damage beyond normal wear, and a signed move-in report is what lets you show the difference.
Do I have to give a tenant notice before entering to make a repair?
Georgia doesn’t set an exact number of hours. Many landlords give about a day’s notice as a courtesy, and your lease should spell it out. Emergencies are handled differently.
Do you mark up repair costs?
No. We bill you what the vendor bills us, and every invoice appears on your monthly statement.
What happens if an approved pet damages the property?
Under our Pet Damage Protection, we handle the repair costs at no extra charge to the owner.
How fast should a landlord respond to a repair request?
Urgent issues like no AC in summer or an active leak deserve a same-day response. Routine requests should still get a quick answer. Check your lease for any response times you’ve committed to.